Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frederick Hastings's avatar

While seeking flawlessness, it can often be observed that one purposely avoids perfection. Rather than look directly at the bright light that reveals truth, for example, we look slightly away lest it blind us. And here’s a piece from a seller of Navajo blankets, touching on the same theme:

Intentional Flaw?  Deliberate Mistake?  Perfectly Imperfect?

Recently a new collector inquired about how much would a weavings value and collectability be diminished if the weaver made a mistake in the mirror image of the design.  The answer is zero.

Navajo are deeply religious.  They believe nothing is perfect, except for the Gods.  They were given the gift of weaving by the Gods and taught by Spiderwoman herself - an important deity to the Navajo.  To honor the Gods, Navajo weavers deliberately incorporate an imperfection.

Indeed, “The optimal amount of irrationality, I am forced to conclude, might not be zero.”

Expand full comment
Lila Krishna's avatar

I think you miss a key reason this stuff works - it’s Making Sacred. When you Make Sacred, things work better than if you didn’t.

They say fasting is good. But it’s hard to persist unless you take it seriously with bhakti, like Ekadashi fasting. I also have role models to follow, e.g. my grandma who would fast without fail on all the fasting days, and was the definition of pious, and never cut corners. I look at her and despite all her hardships, it felt like the hand of the gods was on her.

Same with Saraswati Puja and Ayudha Puja. You’re taking an entire day to just acknowledge the tools of your trade. I’m married a white man who was raised atheist, and he will painstakingly apply kumkum and chandan to each of his power tools and thank them for working well. That feeling of oneness with your tools makes you acknowledge what you have. Our daughter picks the books she wants Ma Saraswati to bless the most, and there is a divinity in that choice.

It’s the same reason Konmari, that is rooted in Shinto practices, works - you acknowledge your possessions and imbue them with life. It makes you take them seriously and reckon with them.

I have an atheist branch of the family. They won’t do things because ‘tradition’. If anything, they’ll go straight up against something traditional. They are also always seeking why, but will stop at midwit answers. They’ll organize events all at the wrong muhurtam. Predictably (IMO), they aren’t doing that well. I look at their lives and try to see why, rationally. They were the family that would eat maggi and drink rasna when all the others in the family eschewed these things for being ‘foreign’. They’d eat meat when no one else in the family did. This part, I explain by saying they made dietary choices they had no context for and didn’t know how to integrate into their life, and in order to make those choices, they turned their backs on stuff that worked fine for their genotype for at least 300 years of recorded family history.

Even their personal lives are a mess… my mom attributes that to not marrying according to a muhurtam. When I think about how they did that, it strikes me that your marriage is the most important decision of your life, and if you use that to make a statement about your lack of belief in astrology, that’s not exactly taking your marriage very seriously. Once when one of their marriages was in trouble, a relative asked them to try sleeping facing a certain direction because it was supposed to help. They didn’t, they were like “what difference does that make?”. Well, it shows you're trying, at the very least.

I’m a fourth-generation astrology enthusiast. Only my uncle did astrology as a profession, but everyone else is well-versed in it as a hobby. We found my great-grandpa’s diaries fifty years after his death, and ten years after my grandpa’s death. He’d noted down the year my grandpa would die… and it was correct! He wasn’t even known as an astrologer!

My mom and I are now studying astrology very seriously. We’ve always been able to read charts, but now we’re looking at the whole spectrum of what’s needed. I feel like most astrologers are so bad at explaining what they are looking at to people who don’t believe. It’s like you’re trying to find the exact configuration of the sky at a particular location at a particular moment in time, and then you consult charts that talk about each kind of configuration and the effects it has. You’re trying to figure out what all the different forces acting at that particular moment will do in conjuction, and that’s where the astronomy and math end and the experience and intuition begin. Prediction is so hard because you’re essentially taking bets on small probabilities. The mistake I see many people, including my mom make, is they presume to know the life of the person whose horoscope they are looking at. Like they’d say “don’t buy stocks, speculation is supposed to go bad for you”. But… what if you’re buying something solid, like a dividend stock that hasn’t moved much in the past five years, is that still speculation? That’s where they get it wrong. And that’s what I’m trying to be better about using a more intuitive approach.

As to why certain planetary configurations lead to real-world effects, we dont know. But we don’t have to reason to pattern-match, like how an LLM knows what to say by just looking at a zillion web pages. So astrology works pretty well that way.

What frustrates me, even among people who are scientifically minded and follow astrology is they don’t try to go deep enough or hard enough in reasoning what the connections are between planets and people, or lines on the palm and personality. It’s one of the things I plan to do (we already know a lot of your palm configuration is based on hormones) when I have the time.

I write historical fiction based on real events. One of the places my astrological knowledge helps me is to look at the horoscopes of the real-world characters I’m writing about, and use that to understand their character and their internal monologue. It’s wild how informative it can be.

Expand full comment

No posts